Pin it
This DIY pumpkin spice coffee add-in turns regular coffee into a snug autumn treat without the fake stuff or high cost of commercial options. The deep, warming taste captures all the cozy vibes of pumpkin spice drinks in an easy homemade mix.
I came up with this after wasting too much cash on fancy seasonal coffee drinks. Now this creamer is part of my morning routine, and whenever friends drop by in fall, they always beg me for my secret.
Essential Components
- Heavy whipping cream: Gives that smooth, rich feel that makes coffee shop drinks so good. Try to get cream with no extras added for the best taste.
- Sweetened condensed milk: Adds both silky texture and sweetness all at once. It makes a thick, tasty foundation.
- Milk: Cuts the richness while adding more to your batch. 2% works perfectly, but go with whole milk if you want it extra creamy.
- Pumpkin puree: Brings real flavor and a light orange tint. Make sure you grab plain canned pumpkin instead of the pre-sweetened pie filling.
- Pumpkin pie spice: Delivers that classic autumn taste blend. Get a new container for stronger aroma.
- Vanilla extract: Rounds out the flavors with warmth. Real extract tastes way better than the fake stuff.
How To Make It
- Mix Your Liquids First:
- Pour heavy whipping cream, sweetened condensed milk, and 2% milk into a medium pot. This starts your creamy foundation before adding any flavors.
- Blend Everything Well:
- Mix these liquids until they're totally smooth. Don't skip this part - you don't want any sugary clumps hiding in your finished creamer.
- Put In The Flavor Makers:
- Drop in your pumpkin puree, pumpkin pie spice, and vanilla extract. Stir again until everything's mixed through the liquid. You'll see a light orange color with tiny spice flecks.
- Warm It Up:
- Set your pot on medium heat. Warm everything for 4-6 minutes, always stirring. The warmth helps blend flavors and wake up the spices, but don't let it boil or you'll mess up the texture.
- Let It Chill:
- Take it off the heat and wait until it's completely cool before you put it away. Cooling stops water drops from forming inside your container which would water down your creamer.
- Keep It Fresh:
- Pour into a sealed container and stick it in the fridge. It'll get a bit thicker as it cools, making it just right for coffee.
Pin it
The pumpkin puree stands out as the star ingredient because it adds true pumpkin taste beyond just the spices. My family knows autumn has officially started when they spot that jar of homemade creamer sitting in our fridge door.
Keeping It Fresh
How you store this creamer really affects how long it lasts and how good it tastes. Always use a clean glass container with a solid lid for best results. Your homemade mix will naturally separate while sitting in the fridge, which is totally normal since it doesn't have the artificial stabilizers. Just shake it up before pouring and everything mixes back together perfectly. If you notice it smells off or looks weird before the week is up, throw it out since dairy can go bad without warning.
Make It Your Own
This basic recipe works great as a starting point for your own spin. Want it less sweet? Cut back to 3/4 cup condensed milk and add a bit more regular milk to balance. Craving stronger pumpkin vibes? Bump up to 4 tablespoons of puree plus another 1/2 teaspoon of pumpkin pie spice. For fancy occasions, try adding a touch of almond extract or toss in a cinnamon stick while heating to create deeper flavor layers. If you're watching your sugar, you can try using sugar-free condensed milk, though it'll come out a little thinner.
Ways To Enjoy It
This creamer does more than jazz up coffee. Try mixing it into hot chai for a pumpkin-chai mashup. Splash some into hot cocoa for a fall-themed drink. On weekends, mix it into your French toast batter or pour it over pancakes instead of maple syrup. Make quick pumpkin spice ice cream by freezing the creamer in an ice cream maker with an extra cup of heavy cream. When guests come over during the holidays, set it out so everyone can fix their coffee just how they like it.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What are non-dairy alternatives for this mix?
Substitute the cream with cream of coconut and swap out regular milk for almond milk to keep it dairy-free.
- → Which type of pumpkin works best here?
Stick to canned pumpkin puree for a smooth texture. Skip fresh pumpkin or pie filling to avoid unexpected flavors.
- → How long will this last in the fridge?
Keep it in a sealed container in your fridge for up to a week. Give it a good shake before pouring.
- → Is it possible to tweak the sweetness or thickness?
Absolutely. Change the proportions of cream, condensed milk, and regular milk to suit your taste preferences.
- → What if I don’t have pie spices handy?
Make your own mix using cinnamon, cloves, allspice, nutmeg, and ginger, balancing the amounts to match your liking.
- → How should I enjoy this creamer?
Add it to iced or hot coffee for a warm, seasonal flavor boost. Shake before using to keep things evenly blended.