Pin it
DIY Samoas bring the iconic Girl Scout favorite to your own kitchen, combining buttery shortbread base, sticky caramel, golden coconut, and smooth chocolate. These handcrafted goodies taste just like what you remember, plus you'll feel extra proud knowing you made them yourself.
I spent many weekends tweaking this till it was just right, and honestly, I enjoyed every minute. When your house fills with the smell of toasty coconut and melty chocolate, it's pure kitchen happiness that takes you back in time.
Key Ingredients Breakdown
- Butter: Go for European types with extra butterfat to get the crunchiest shortbread base.
- Coconut: Grab sweetened shredded coconut for the right chewiness; don't try using the dry desiccated stuff.
- Caramels: Soft ones like Werther's will give you that perfect stretchy, chewy layer.
- Chocolate: Splurge on good melting wafers for that shiny, smooth finish that snaps when bitten.
Making Them From Scratch
- First: Cookie Base
- Make sure your butter and flour stay chilled for the most tender, crispy shortbread texture possible.
- Second: Getting Coconut Ready
- Brown your coconut until it's golden and fragrant, stirring often so it doesn't burn at the edges.
- Third: Working With Caramel
- Take your time melting those caramels, giving them constant attention to create a smooth, even mixture.
- Fourth: Putting It All Together
- Be patient and precise with each layer to create treats that look amazing and taste even better.
Pin it
The first batch I made with my little girl brought double happiness - we weren't just recreating something we loved from my childhood, we were also super proud of how beautiful and tasty they turned out.
Keeping Them Fresh And Giving
- Keep these treats somewhere cool and dry with parchment between layers so they don't stick together.
- Toss in a bread slice with stored cookies to keep the caramel soft and chewy longer.
- Pack them in cute tins or fancy boxes when giving them as gifts to friends.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I use homemade caramel instead of store-bought?
- Absolutely, just make sure your homemade caramel is thick enough to stick the coconut mixture together properly.
- → Why do you need to toast the coconut?
- Toasting brings out the coconut's nutty flavor and gives it a nice crunch that works well with the sticky caramel.
- → Can I make these cookies smaller or larger?
- Sure, just watch your baking time. Smaller ones need less time in the oven, bigger ones need more.
- → How do you prevent the chocolate from blooming?
- Mix a bit of oil into your melted chocolate and keep the finished cookies at room temp, not in the fridge.
- → Can I freeze the unbaked cookie dough?
- The shortbread dough freezes great for up to 3 months. Just let it thaw in your fridge overnight before you use it.