Pin it
These DIY peppermint patties hit that sweet spot between deep dark chocolate coating and cool, fluffy peppermint inside. They're way better than anything from the store, with pure flavors that come from quality ingredients and careful making. When you bite in, you get that nice chocolate crack before the center melts away - it's like having your own little candy shop moment right at home.
I've played around with this recipe for ages, and these homemade mint patties always wow everyone from casual snackers to serious sweet tooth folks. There's something really satisfying about making candy that looks store-bought but tastes so much better.
Essential Ingredient Picks
- Sweetened condensed milk: Go for a fancy brand with good milk flavor for super creamy middles
- Pure peppermint extract: Try to find oil-based instead of alcohol-based for cleaner, stronger mint taste
- Real vanilla extract: Actual vanilla works with the mint to create deeper flavor
- Powdered sugar: Make sure to sift it well so your centers aren't grainy
- Dark chocolate candy melts: Try to get ones with 60% cacao or more for the best taste
- Fun sprinkles: Pick colors that match your party or holiday theme
- Kosher salt: Just a tiny bit makes all the flavors pop without tasting salty
Crafting Flawless Patties
- Base Mixture:
- Start with condensed milk that isn't cold. Mix in your flavor extracts before you add any sugar.
- Getting The Right Dough:
- Put in sugar bit by bit and mix until it feels like soft clay. It should hold its shape but not stick to everything.
- How To Roll Them:
- Work small batches and keep the rest cold. Roll between two sheets of parchment for even thickness.
- Cutting Them Out:
- Dunk your cutter in powdered sugar between cuts. Don't take too long or the dough warms up.
- Freezing Step:
- Put cut patties on parchment paper trays with gaps between them. Freeze until they're totally hard.
Pin it
I first started making these during Christmas baking with my grandma, who always said taking your time and being exact is what makes candies amazing instead of just okay.
Beautiful Serving Ideas
Try showing off your mint patties on a fancy silver stand with paper doilies underneath. They make great gifts when placed in mini cupcake papers and packed in pretty tins. For parties, lay them out on a mirror with some fresh mint leaves and sparkly sugar around them. You can also stack them in see-through bags tied with ribbons for party favors or sweet little presents.
Fun Twists To Try
Play around with different chocolate coatings for new flavors. White chocolate makes them sweeter, or you can swirl dark and white for a cool look. Sprinkle crushed candy canes on top while still wet for extra crunch and Christmas flair. Cut them into different shapes using holiday cookie cutters, or add some food coloring to the filling for themed parties. You can even make tiny ones for bite-size treats.
Keeping Them Fresh
Put your patties in a container that seals tight, with wax paper between the layers so they don't stick together. They'll stay perfect in the fridge for about three weeks or in the freezer for three months. Let them sit out for about 10 minutes before eating so they warm up a bit - they taste better and the mint flavor really comes out then.
Pin it
I've made countless batches of these mint patties over the years, and they've become my go-to homemade candy. Making them takes me back to sweet holiday baking memories while letting me share something really special with friends and family. Seeing someone's face light up when they taste that perfect mix of chocolate and mint makes all the careful work worth it.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I swap candy melts for normal chocolate?
- Sure, but candy melts work better since they harden nicely and don't need the careful tempering regular chocolate does.
- → How long will these patties stay good?
- They'll keep fresh for about 2 weeks when stored in a sealed container in your fridge.
- → Why must I freeze the patties before coating them?
- Freezing keeps them firm and stops them from melting when they hit the warm chocolate.
- → Can I make these without buying a cookie cutter?
- Absolutely, just roll little balls of the mixture and press them flat with your fingers.
- → How can I tell if my mixture has the perfect texture?
- It should be firm enough to shape without sticking to your hands, but not so dry that it falls apart.