Pin it
Making peanut butter cups at home turns an ordinary candy into something special, with a lovely mix of chocolate exterior and smooth peanut filling inside. This method makes mouthwatering treats that beat anything from the store, thanks to their freshness, better ingredients, and how you can adjust the sweetness just how you like it.
I first whipped these up when my little girl couldn't handle certain food additives. What started out of need quickly turned into our family's favorite activity, with everyone jumping in to help swirl chocolate and check if the filling tastes good enough.
Key Components
- Dark Chocolate: Go for top-notch couverture chocolate that's at least 60% cocoa for better melting and a nice shine.
- Peanut Butter: Pick natural, freshly ground stuff for the fullest taste. Skip brands with extra oils as they'll mess with the texture.
- Honey: Get raw honey to add more depth to your filling while helping it reach just the right thickness.
- Powdered Sugar: Make sure your powdered sugar is fresh and smooth for a creamy filling. You'll need different amounts depending on how sweet your peanut butter already is.
Directions
- Step 1: Chocolate Selection
- Start by getting your chocolate tempered right. Snap it into tiny, similar-sized bits for even melting. If you're using your microwave, keep it at half power so it doesn't burn. The chocolate should only feel slightly warm when you touch it, around 88-90°F (31-32°C).
- Step 2: Base Formation
- As you coat the paper cups, make small circles to get an even layer. Watch those sides - they need to be thick enough to hold everything but thin enough to bite easily. Look for chocolate that's shiny and perfectly smooth.
- Step 3: Filling Preparation
- Combine your filling stuff bit by bit, with peanut butter and honey first. Drop in powdered sugar one spoon at a time until everything holds its shape but stays creamy. You should be able to roll it into little balls without it sticking all over your fingers.
- Step 4: Final Assembly
- For the top chocolate layer, pour from the middle and move outward so you don't trap air. Lightly tap the muffin tin against your counter to let the chocolate settle and make a flat top.
Pin it
We found out by accident that if you let the cups sit out for about 5 minutes before taking a bite, they're absolutely perfect - the filling gets just a bit softer while the chocolate still breaks with that satisfying crack.
Pin it
Through countless batches of these peanut butter cups, I've learned that taking your time and focusing on little details makes all the difference. Though they're pretty straightforward to put together, not rushing each step gives you treats that look like they came from a fancy chocolate shop. There's something extra sweet about making them yourself and sharing them with friends and family.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I throw in frozen bananas instead?
- Absolutely, frozen bananas will make your drink even thicker and more lush.
- → What's the point of adding lemon juice?
- The lemon juice brightens the banana taste and keeps the fruit from turning brown.
- → Can I skip the ice cream completely?
- Sure thing, just use frozen banana pieces and a bit more milk for a lighter version.
- → Which milk works best?
- Full-fat milk gives the creamiest results, but any milk works fine including almond, oat or soy.
- → Is it OK to make this beforehand?
- These shakes taste way better right after you blend them for the nicest texture.