Pin it
Got to spill about my ultimate sweet treat - this mind-blowing Reese's Cheesecake that brings together life's tastiest flavors. Whipped this up for my boy's big day and now everyone begs for it at parties. Imagine this: smooth peanut butter filling packed with chopped Reese's cups sitting on a dark Oreo base with velvety ganache on top. It's just unreal.
This Dessert Will Change Your World
Believe me, we're not talking ordinary cheesecake here. My little trick? Adding sour cream for that melt-in-your-mouth texture that cuts through all that chocolate peanut butter richness. Never made cheesecake before? Don't worry, you've got this. And you can fix it up a day early when you've got company coming.
Grab These Ingredients
- Oreos: Stick with original ones, not the Double Stuff for your base
- Unsalted Butter: Quality stuff, melted down and ready
- Cream Cheese: Go full-fat and make sure it's completely softened
- Peanut Butter: I swear by smooth JIF every single time
- Mini Reese's Cups: Buy more than needed, you'll munch while cooking
- Sour Cream: This gives everything that luscious texture
- Heavy Whipping Cream: Needed for our smooth topping and ganache
Kitchen Steps Made Simple
- Creating Your Base
- Smash those Oreos, blend with melted butter and push into your springform. A short bake sets it just right.
- Whipping Up The Middle
- Get that cream cheese super fluffy, mix in your peanut butter goodies, then gently add those Reese's bits.
- Don't Skip The Bath
- Trust me here - seal your pan carefully and place in some hot water, it really makes a difference.
- Finish With Flair
- After cooling, drizzle that shiny ganache, add some peanut butter swirls and top it off with Reese's pieces.
Pro Tips From My Kitchen
I've made this tons of times and learned some handy tricks. Everything needs to be room temp or you'll get bumps. Always mix slowly to avoid air pockets. Cool it gradually with the oven door slightly open to stop cracking. And don't rush when warming your ganache.
Storage Smarts
This showstopper stays good in your fridge about 5 days if wrapped well. Need to make it super early? Stick it in the freezer without the whipped topping and it'll last three months. Just let it thaw overnight when you need it.
Pin it
Tasty Twists
I sometimes toss crushed pretzels in the base for extra crunch. A little caramel drizzle takes it to another level. And if you want to go completely over the top, serve it with some vanilla ice cream and warm fudge sauce for pure joy.
The Magic Factor
This isn't your average cheesecake recipe but a true celebration on a plate. The way the smooth meets crunchy and sweet plays with salty, it checks all the boxes. Whenever I bring this to gatherings, people actually stop talking when they see it.
Learned From Experience
After so many bakes, I've picked up some wisdom. Splurge on fancy cream cheese and chocolate, you'll notice it in the taste. Plan ahead since it gets way better after chilling overnight. Add that ganache while it's still slightly warm for the glossiest look. And my trick for clean slices? Dunk your knife in hot water between cuts.
More Peanut Butter Treats
Still craving that Reese's flavor? You should check out my other hits: My super easy no-bake Reese's Peanut Butter Pie perfect when it's hot outside, Those crazy good Reese's Brownies that vanish instantly, And my talked-about Reese's Cookie Cake that's now famous at kids' parties.
Sweet Thoughts To End
This cheesecake has truly become part of our family traditions. There's something wonderful about carrying it to the table, seeing everyone get excited, and enjoying those first bites together. Whether you're marking something important or just want the best chocolate peanut butter dessert ever, this will make everyone happy.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why use ingredients at room temperature?
Warmer ingredients mix better without clumps, creating a smoother cheesecake texture. Cold ones can mess up the consistency.
- → What’s the water bath for?
This method keeps the cheesecake moist, cooks it evenly, and minimizes cracks on top. The gentle heat really pays off!
- → Can this cheesecake be frozen?
Definitely! Skip the whipped cream on top, wrap tightly, and freeze for 3 months. Just let it thaw in the fridge before digging in.
- → Why is my whipped cream runny?
Over-mixing after adding peanut butter can break the cream down. Just whip until stiff peaks show, then stop!
- → Can I substitute Reese's with other types?
Sure! Mini Reese's work best for more chocolate per bite. Bigger or wrapped ones have less peanut butter to balance the flavors.
Conclusion
Layers of rich cheesecake, chocolate, and peanut butter come together for a sweet treat made for celebrations or serious dessert cravings.