Tasty Panera Chicken Avocado Sandwich

This homemade take on Panera's famous Chipotle Chicken Avocado Melt delivers an irresistible combo of toasty bread, melted cheese, and smoky goodness. You'll have this mouthwatering sandwich ready in just 15 minutes, featuring juicy shredded rotisserie chicken, buttery avocado, zesty chipotle mayo, and gooey gouda cheese that'll make your tastebuds dance.

From my time working as a sandwich expert, I found that giving your fully built sandwich about a minute to sit before hitting the grill helps the chipotle mayo soak slightly into the bread, taking the flavor up several notches.

Key Components Breakdown

• Fresh focaccia: Works as the ideal base thanks to its robust build and herb-infused taste
• Ripe avocado: Should feel slightly soft when gently squeezed for that smooth, buttery texture
• Rotisserie chicken: Pick a premium one for the best mix of taste and time-saving convenience
• Aged gouda: Melts beautifully while adding nutty flavor notes
• Chipotle mayo: Adds smoky heat and silky richness throughout the sandwich

Crafting Your Ultimate Sandwich

Start with your spicy spread:

Mix mayo with finely diced chipotles, making sure the heat gets evenly distributed throughout.

Set up your assembly area:

Get everything ready before you start building. Make sure your bread's cut and all ingredients are within reach.

Stack strategically:

Slather both bread pieces with plenty of chipotle mayo, then put down your cheese base first.

Nail the cooking approach:

Warm your pan until water droplets dance slightly. Place your sandwich down and apply gentle pressure with your spatula.

Finish with steam magic:

Sprinkle water into the pan and quickly cover it to trap moisture that helps your cheese get perfectly gooey.

Pin it

I picked up an amazing trick from a veteran sandwich maker who taught me to brush the bread's outside with a tiny bit of chipotle mayo before grilling. This creates a stunning golden outside with an extra hint of smoky flavor that totally transforms this sandwich.

Heat Control Tips

Getting that perfect melt needs careful attention to heat throughout cooking. Start with medium-high heat to get that initial crispy exterior, then turn it down a bit so the cheese can fully melt without burning your bread. Adding that splash of water and covering at the end brings everything together while keeping the outside nice and crunchy.

Layering Tricks

Your success comes down to smart ingredient stacking. Start with cheese on both pieces of bread to create a moisture shield that keeps your bread from getting soggy. Put chicken in the center, then add avocado and peppers. This setup guarantees the best texture. Press everything lightly when building to keep it all in place without flattening your bread.

Prep Work Shortcuts

Make sandwich-making easier by getting stuff ready ahead of time. The chipotle mayo actually tastes better when it sits overnight. Pull your chicken apart and get other ingredients ready, but wait until the last second to cut your avocado so it doesn't turn brown.

Mix It Up Options

This flexible sandwich can handle creative twists while staying true to its roots. Want more heat? Throw in extra chipotle peppers or some fresh jalapeños. Try adding crispy bacon for crunch and extra smokiness. Looking for something lighter? Go with sourdough bread or add some fresh tomato slices.

Keeping It Fresh

While these taste amazing hot off the pan, you can save them for later too. Keep built but uncooked sandwiches wrapped tight in your fridge for up to a day. When you're ready to eat, let them sit out for about 15 minutes before grilling to get the best results.

Pin it

After making this sandwich hundreds of times, I've found that what really counts are the small things - from how warm your ingredients are to the order you put them together. When you hit that sweet spot of crunchy outside, gooey inside, and balanced flavors, you'll see why this sandwich has become such a hit. It's more than just a quick meal; it's a little bit of sandwich heaven right in your own kitchen.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I mix the chipotle mayo beforehand?

Absolutely, you can make the chipotle mayo up to 3 days early and keep it in a sealed container in your fridge.

→ What can I use instead of peppadew peppers?

Try sweet and spicy cherry peppers, or go with roasted red peppers plus a dash of red pepper flakes.

→ How do I stop the avocado turning brown?

Drizzle the cut avocado with lemon juice if you're prepping the sandwich in advance - this stops it from discoloring.

→ Can I switch the bread type?

Though focaccia gives the most true-to-original taste, ciabatta or sourdough work well too - just pick something sturdy enough for all those fillings.

→ Why should I add water when cooking?

The water makes steam that helps the cheese melt completely and warms everything through evenly while keeping the bread nice and crisp.