Pin it
Transform your regular weeknight meals with tandoori chicken that's bursting with spicy aromas and juicy meat. This one-pan approach gives you all that authentic taste without the messy cleanup, making it just right for those busy nights when you want something special. The chicken comes out of the oven richly colored and aromatic, while the spiced potatoes get nice and crispy, soaking up all those same delicious flavors that make the chicken so good.
When I first made this for a family get-together, amazing smells filled my kitchen and everyone wandered in before I'd even called them for dinner. My super fussy nephew helped himself to multiple servings, and my mother-in-law asked me to write down the recipe before she left. There's just something about chicken that's been tenderized in yogurt alongside those perfectly seasoned potatoes that makes a meal nobody can turn down.
Must-Have Ingredients Breakdown
- Chicken pieces with bones: Keep meat juicy and full of flavor during cooking
- Lemon juice: Brings a zesty kick and helps soften the meat
- Soy sauce: Adds deep savory flavors and perfect saltiness
- Red pepper paste: Gives that true color and mild heat
- Plain cooking oil: Helps everything stay moist while roasting
- Kashmiri chili powder: Adds amazing color without too much spiciness
- Cumin powder: Creates a rich earthy base for all the flavors
- Ground coriander: Adds lemony notes that work well with chicken
- Turmeric: Brings golden color and light earthiness
- Black pepper: Gives just the right spicy balance
- Garam masala: Adds warm aromatic depth
- Dried fenugreek leaves: Brings that real tandoori taste
- Baking soda: Works wonders to make chicken tender
- Ginger garlic paste: Makes the foundation of all good flavors
- Thick Greek yogurt: Softens and flavors the meat perfectly
- Yellow potatoes: Hold their shape while soaking up all the tastes
Foolproof Cooking Method
- Making the Marinade:
- Mix Greek yogurt, lemon juice, soy sauce, red pepper paste, oil, and all your spices in a big glass bowl. Stir everything until you get a smooth, thick mixture.
- Getting Chicken Ready:
- Take a sharp knife and make deep diagonal cuts across each chicken piece, going almost to the bone. Sprinkle chicken with salt before putting it in the marinade.
- Coating Everything Well:
- Push the chicken down into the marinade, using your hands to work the mixture into the cuts and under the skin.
- Letting It Sit:
- Cover the bowl tightly with plastic and put it in the fridge for at least an hour, though leaving it overnight works much better.
- Working with Potatoes:
- Cut your yellow potatoes into even wedges. After taking the chicken out, toss these potato pieces in whatever marinade is left until they're well covered.
- Setting Up the Pan:
- Put your marinated chicken on a sheet pan with some room between pieces. Spread the potato wedges in one layer around the chicken.
- Cooking It Right:
- Bake in your hot oven until chicken hits the right temperature inside and potatoes turn golden with crispy edges.
- Finishing Touches:
- Let the chicken sit a bit before serving. Throw some fresh chopped cilantro and lemon wedges on top for extra flavor.
Pin it
My kids really love how the potatoes soak up all those tandoori flavors, making them the perfect match for the chicken. They were unsure about the bright orange color at first, but now they specifically ask for the "orange potatoes" whenever they see chicken on our weekly menu.
Impressive Serving Suggestions
Make your meal complete by adding cool cucumber raita and fluffy basmati rice. When friends come over, serve it with some warm naan bread and a simple salad of tomatoes and onions with a splash of lime juice.
Easy Twists
Try using boneless chicken thighs if you want it to cook faster. This marinade works great with firm fish like salmon or even cauliflower chunks for a meat-free option. You can also throw some sliced red onions and bell peppers onto the pan for the last fifteen minutes of cooking time.
Smart Storage
Keep any leftover chicken and potatoes in sealed containers in your fridge for up to three days. When reheating, put them in a 300°F oven covered with foil so they don't dry out. Any chicken you have left makes really good wraps or tops for salads.
Pin it
What makes this tandoori chicken sheet pan dinner so great is how it turns basic ingredients into something amazing. The mix of spices creates flavor layers that seem way more fancy than the work you put in. This dish shows you don't need complicated methods or fancy equipment to get real, authentic tastes.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I use boneless chicken for this tandoori recipe?
- Absolutely, boneless chicken thighs or breasts work fine, but you'll need to cook them for less time, about 20-25 minutes or until they hit 165°F. While bone-in pieces usually taste richer, boneless is great when you're in a hurry.
- → What can I substitute for Greek yogurt if I don't have any?
- Regular plain yogurt works just as well. If you need a dairy-free option, try coconut yogurt, though it'll change the taste a bit. The yogurt helps make the chicken tender, so it's best to include some kind of yogurt.
- → Where can I find Kashmiri red chili powder?
- You can grab Kashmiri chili powder at Indian grocery stores or from online shops. If you can't get it, mix 3/4 teaspoon sweet paprika with 1/4 teaspoon cayenne for a similar look and kick.
- → What vegetables can I add to this sheet pan dinner?
- Bell peppers, cauliflower, sliced carrots, or chunky onions go really well with the potatoes. Just cut everything about the same size so they cook evenly, and coat them in the same mixture as the potatoes.
- → Can I marinate the chicken for longer than 24 hours?
- While the chicken tastes great after marinating up to 24 hours, going longer isn't a good idea. The lemon juice and yogurt are acidic and can break down the meat too much, leaving you with mushy chicken instead of tender pieces.