Pin it
Coconut milk brings a silky finish to this butternut squash creation, while slow-roasted squash brings natural sweetness and a toasty flavor. When the air turns crisp and the leaves go gold, nothing beats this bowl for comfort. It’s what I crave when I want to snuggle up with something warm and satisfying.
I first tossed together this soup during a chilly autumn with barely any motivation to cook all day. But turning the oven on for the squash and swirling in coconut milk? Next-level comfort. Now, friends ask for it every time it gets cold outside.
Creamy Ingredients List
- Butternut squash: The main sweet flavor here. Choose one that's heavy and has firm skin without marks
- Olive oil: Gets the squash golden in the oven and softens the aromatics on the stove
- Sweet onion: Adds a mellow background sweetness that goes with the squash. Fresh onions with no mushy patches are best
- Garlic cloves: For warmth and subtle kick—use fresh, not jarred, for best results
- Fresh ginger: Gives gentle heat and depth. Pick firm pieces with smooth skin
- Full-fat coconut milk: Brings the best, creamy texture. Shake the can before using so it's all mixed together
- Vegetable broth: Makes the soup thinner and savory. Homemade’s awesome if you have it
- Cayenne pepper: Brings a bit of fire to balance the sweetness. Don’t overdo it—a pinch is plenty
- Cinnamon: Adds a warm, homey aroma and sweet touch
- Salt: Brings every flavor out. Kosher salt gives you the most even flavor
Easy Step-By-Step Directions
- Finish & reheat:
- Move the blended soup back into the pot and gently warm for a couple of minutes. Stir so it doesn’t stick. Taste and sprinkle in more salt or spice if you like. Pour into bowls and go wild with your favorite toppings.
- Blend it up:
- Once the squash is cool enough, scoop it out and toss it in your blender with the coconut milk mix. Blend until it’s velvety smooth—just let it run for a few minutes so it’s extra creamy.
- Mix the soup base:
- Add coconut milk and veggie broth to the pot, making sure to catch all the good bits at the bottom. Shake in your cinnamon, cayenne, and salt. Cover and let it gently bubble on low so the flavors meld for about five minutes.
- Get the aromatics going:
- While the oven is doing its job, heat olive oil in a big pot and cook chopped onion until it’s super soft, maybe 3-4 minutes. Toss in garlic and ginger, stir for half a minute, and don't let the garlic brown—it can taste weird.
- Roast the squash:
- Put the squash halves (flesh-side down) on a lined baking sheet and roast at 425°F for 40-45 minutes. You want the skin a bit browned and soft enough that a knife slides right in. Getting those caramelized edges is the magic!
- Prep your squash:
- Slice your squash in half down the middle, dig out the seeds, and rub the whole cut side with olive oil and salt. Cover every spot—more is better!
Pin it
Fresh ginger really brings this soup to life. I’ve made it without and it’s just not the same. Ginger warms things up and gives complexity. Even my husband, who usually dodges orange veggies, asks for this all season.
Best Soup Toppers
The right extras can take your bowl from just good to seriously amazing. Pour on a swirl of coconut milk for pretty contrast. Sprinkle with toasted pumpkin seeds so you get a nice crunch. Top with fresh parsley or cilantro—that little pop of green cuts the richness and tastes super fresh.
Customize Your Bowl
Adjust this however you want. More cayenne or a scoop of red curry paste will heat things up. Prefer a thinner soup? Just add extra broth until it looks how you like. Amp up the sweetness and depth with a bit of maple syrup if you’re feeling it.
Effortless Meal Planning
Turn this soup into a full dinner—serve it with a filling grain salad or really good bread. Want it ready for later? Make double and stash single servings in the freezer. It warms up perfectly for a quick lunch or dinner on even the busiest nights.
Pin it
This is the easiest way to bring fall vibes to your table, and it always wows family and friends—no fuss required.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I swap in light coconut milk for full-fat?
Sure, light coconut milk works if that’s all you have, but the soup won’t taste as rich or feel as smooth. Full-fat kicks in extra creamy vibes and really brings out the coconut flavor with butternut squash.
- → How'll I know when butternut squash is roasted just right?
You want your squash to get fork-tender and have a bit of browning on the edges. Usually takes 40-45 minutes at 425°F. That golden color means more flavor and sweeter bites for your soup.
- → What goes well with this butternut squash soup?
This soup loves bread on the side, a fresh leafy salad, or even a toasty grilled cheese. For fancier gatherings, serve as a small starter. Toppings like parsley and crunchy pumpkin seeds are an easy win for looks and crunch.
- → Can I prep this soup in advance?
Definitely! It actually gets tastier after hanging out in the fridge for a day. Keep it in a sealed container for up to 4 days or pop it in the freezer for a couple months. Warm it up gently on the stove if you can, but the microwave is fine for quick reheats.
- → How do I make it spicier or milder?
The little bit of cayenne gives gentle heat. Want more bite? Try 1/4 teaspoon of cayenne. No heat fan? Just leave it out, or swap for some nutmeg for a warm flavor without spice.
- → Is pre-chopped butternut squash okay to use?
Yep, pre-cut squash makes life easier, but you might lose out on those deep caramel flavors from roasting a whole squash. If you use chunks, roast them on a lined baking tray and turn them around a few times so everything browns up nicely.