Pin it
These tiny treasures totally transformed how I do appetizers. I found this idea during a party emergency and now my Stuffed Cream Cheese Mini Peppers vanish first at every get-together. They're super easy with just four things needed and they look stunning on any platter. What's cool? You can eat them cold for extra crunch or warm them up for gooey goodness.
Why You'll Love This Tasty Idea
Your home will become the hangout spot thanks to these peppers. I make them all the time because they work for everyone's food needs without extra effort. They're naturally keto friendly and gluten-free without costing much. And they taste fantastic whether you pull them from the fridge or serve them hot from cooking. That mix of smooth filling with sweet pepper crunch gets me every single time.
What You'll Need
- Mini Sweet Bell Peppers: I buy these colorful little guys in bulk when they're cheap. They last forever in your refrigerator.
- Cream Cheese: The trick is using the whipped kind since it spreads so easily.
- Cheddar Cheese: Shred it yourself if you can the bagged stuff doesn't melt properly.
- Everything Bagel Seasoning: This stuff works magic and adds tons of taste with no work. I keep mine right next to where I cook.
Step By Step Guide
- Prep Your Peppers
- Cut them down the middle and take out seeds. Dry them with some paper toweling.
- Whip Up Your Filling
- Combine the cream cheese cheddar and that bagel seasoning until it's all blended. My stand mixer makes this part quick.
- Stuff Each Half
- Put that yummy mixture into all your pepper pieces. Don't worry about making it look perfect.
- Ready To Eat
- Munch on them right now or heat them up. They're great baked at 350°F for about 15 minutes. Short on time? Try 3-5 minutes in your air fryer instead.
Fun Variations
Sometimes I play around with different fillings. Lately I'm crazy about fluffy ricotta mixed with fresh basil. Adding goat cheese brings amazing flavor and using brie makes them feel extra special. Throwing in some bacon bits takes them to another level. I've even tried spicy sausage when feeding hungry meat-eaters.
Insider Tips
After making these tons of times I've figured out some shortcuts. Whipped cream cheese works way better than regular and using a piping bag makes filling so much quicker. Make sure to dry those peppers really good because nobody wants them watery. Try different spice mixes until you find what you love best.
Pin it
Perfect Serving Ideas
These little guys have rescued me during surprise visitors and fancy dinner parties too. They look amazing next to cheese boards and fit perfectly in packed lunches. I always make more than needed because somehow they disappear faster than I can set them down.
Keeping Them Fresh
Your stuffed peppers will stay good in the fridge up to 3 days in an airtight container. Want them to last longer? Just keep the filling separate from the peppers. This keeps everything crisp and you can stuff them whenever you want a quick bite.
Questions People Ask Me
How are baby bells different from mini sweets? Mini sweets work better for snacks and finger foods. They're tinier and sweeter compared to baby bells which I use more for cooking.
What's the easiest way to clean them? Slice them in half and scrape seeds out with your knife edge. A little tap on your cutting board knocks out any leftovers.
Should I serve them hot or cold? They're good both ways honestly. Cold ones have that nice snap while warm ones get all melty and comforting. At parties I usually put out both kinds.
Quick Prep Tricks
I usually get these ready the day before hosting. For cold snacks they'll stay perfect in your fridge for a full day. If you want them warm wait to cook until people arrive. This way the cheese gets all gooey and melted just right.
Other Crowd Winners
If you enjoyed these peppers then you'll probably like these party hits too: Meat and Cheese Skewers that look fancy but come together quickly, Puff Pastry Brie Bites because warm cheese always wins, Spicy Chicken Flatbread for folks who want some heat. These always get compliments no matter where I bring them.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I prep the peppers in advance?
- Yes, you can! Make them a day before and keep them covered in the fridge. Heat before serving or serve cold if preferred.
- → How do I store leftover mini peppers?
- Place any extras in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 3 days. While the peppers might soften slightly, they'll still taste good.
- → Can I switch up the cheese filling?
- Of course! Try swapping in mozzarella, goat cheese, or pepper jack for a different flavor kick.
- → Why do cooked peppers get soggy?
- Usually it’s from overcooking. Stick to the suggested time and temp to keep that perfect balance of tender and crunchy.
- → What’s a good alternative to bagel seasoning?
- You can mix sesame seeds, dried garlic, onion, and salt. Or go with Italian or taco seasoning for a twist.